6 Putters Under $250 Worth Checking Out

In case you’ve been hiding under a rock, here’s some news: putters aren’t cheap. If you’re comfortable spending $400 to $500, good for you. However, plenty of golfers either don’t see the value or simply don’t want to pay that much. The good news is you don’t have to because there are good putters available well below that premium price tier.

This isn’t a list of the best putters of 2025 and it’s not about declaring an outright winner. Instead, these are six putters under $250 that are available, worth testing and, in some cases, backed by MyGolfSpy testing results.

Cleveland’s HB Soft 2 line continues to be one of the most reliable value options. The speed-optimized face milling helps maintain more consistent ball speed on mishits which can be just as important as feel. If you want modern performance at a fair price. this is an easy place to start.

The Infinite Buckingham isn’t just a budget mallet; it’s a proven one. Wilson’s counterbalanced design adds stability and helps smooth the stroke and it didn’t go unnoticed in testing, earning Best Mallet of 2025 honors. It’s a strong reminder that performance doesn’t always scale with price.

The Anser is one of the most iconic putter shapes and the 2024 version sticks closely to that winning formula. At $219 right now, it offers a classic feel and clean visuals from one of the most trusted names in putting. If you like a traditional blade with zero distractions, this one still deserves a roll.

Odyssey’s Microhinge insert is designed to promote faster forward roll and more consistent distance control. The Seven S shape adds forgiveness and stability compared to a blade while maintaining a softer feel off the face. It’s a solid option for golfers who prefer insert technology.

The 2024 Spider Red just sneaks under the $250 threshold and delivers the high-MOI performance the Spider line is known for. Stability on off-center strikes is the main selling point and it remains one of the most confidence-inspiring mallet designs. If mallets suit your eye, this is a familiar option at a more approachable price.

At $129, the Template Maiden Silver is easily the least expensive putter on this list. It features a milled face and a traditional profile that feels far more premium than the price suggests. Tour Edge may fly under the radar but this one is worth testing if value is your priority.